Clean Eats: Italian night

It’s been awhile since I did a Clean Eats post, so I figured I’d share one of my recent go-tos for a quick, easy and tasty Italian night!

I can’t claim this recipe as my own and mucho credit goes to PaleOMG for her brilliance. I’m posting my version with my particular twists and turns, but  the original recipe can be found here. 

First start with a spaghetti squash of a decent size. If you cannot find one that is about the size of a kiddie football, get two small ones like I did. Take a small paring knife and cut that sucker in half with the smaller blade, going all the way around the long side of the squashes. Then my favorite part – to cut through the hard stems, take a larger chef’s or butcher knife and wedge it into the line you’ve already cut. Once it’s stuck in there nice and good, lift the knife and the squash up and bring it down HARD on the counter. The squash stem should break from the force and you’ll have two perfect halves. And you’ll feel like Chuck Norris. :) Then take a big spoon and scoop out all the squash guts. Don’t be shy.

The best way I’ve found to cook spaghetti squash is the old school way – roasted in the oven, cut-side down, on parchment paper with a sprinkle of water. 400 degrees for 30-40 minutes depending on the size. Once you can press down on the top of the squash and it gives, it’s done. I love that this process doesn’t have to be an exact science. Here’s how non-pretty my squash looked when they were cooked and then de-threaded.

Clean Eats: Italian Night |

Add all that lovely goodness to a 9×13 pan.

Clean Eats: Italian Night |

While the squash is cooking, brown your meat of choice in a pan with half a chopped onion and your favorite Italian seasonings. I eyeball dashes of dry spices: salt, oregano, basil, parsley, garlic powder and onion powder. I like having the meat have flavor along with the sauce we’ll use.

Clean Eats: Italian Night |

Once the meat is browned up, add 1 to 1.5 cups of your choice of a clean marinara or pizza sauce. The key is to find one with only real ingredients and no sugar. Rao’s Marinara happens to be my favorite.

Clean Eats: Italian Night |

Then take the sauce/meat combo and add it to the 9×13 with the squash and mix it up well.

Clean Eats: Italian Night |

Whisk 3 eggs nice and well.

Clean Eats: Italian Night |

Pour the eggs directly onto the squash/meat/sauce combo in the 9×13 and mix it all well, until the eggs are incorporated completely into the mixture.

Clean Eats: Italian Night |

Bake this for about 45-55 minutes at 350. You can tell it’s done when the middle isn’t jiggly and it’s assumed a true casserole texture.

Clean Eats: Italian Night |


  • Add cheese. Because, CHEESE!!! I have used fresh mozzarella, feta, Parmesan or a combo of those. This is a great addition for the dairy-tolerant or non-Paleos.
  • Combine meats. Italian sausage is PaleOMG’s choice, but I prefer ground turkey. I’ve also tried grass-fed beef.
  • The sky is the limit. You can’t mess this recipe up. Be creative and add your favorites!
Clean Eats: Italian Night |


Hope y’all enjoy!

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Clean Eats: Italian night

5 Responses

  1. Drool now covers my keyboard… work.

    Nette April 21, 2014 at 12:20 pm #
    • *passes the napkins

      My bad! 😉

      50Peach April 21, 2014 at 3:38 pm #
  2. nom nom nom!! looks delish!! April 23, 2014 at 7:35 am #
  3. Have I ever told you how I’m afraid of trying new foods? Anyway, You’ve almost convinced me to try this.

    I’m still dreaming of coconut pancakes, btw.

    Michelle Longo April 27, 2014 at 7:24 am #
  1. 2016 Refresh: Food, food, glorious food. | 50 Peach - January 26, 2016

    […] My version of PaleOMG’s Almost 5 Ingredient Pizza Spaghetti Pie.  This is a super clean, but super tasty Italian Night option if you’re trying to get back on track. I make this at least every few weeks. The longest time suck is the roasting of the spaghetti squash and cooking it until the mixed in egg is done. But it’s so worth it. […]

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: